B4.10

Logic, Computation and Set Theory
Part II, 2002

Explain what is meant by a well-ordering of a set.

Without assuming Zorn's Lemma, show that the power-set of any well-ordered set can be given a total (linear) ordering.

By a selection function for a set AA, we mean a function f:PAPAf: P A \rightarrow P A such that f(B)Bf(B) \subset B for all BA,f(B)B \subset A, f(B) \neq \emptyset for all BB \neq \emptyset, and f(B)Bf(B) \neq B if BB has more than one element. Suppose given a selection function ff. Given a mapping g:α[0,1]g: \alpha \rightarrow[0,1] for some ordinal α\alpha, we define a subset B(f,g)AB(f, g) \subset A recursively as follows:

B(f,g)=A if α=0,B(f,g)=f(B(f,gβ)) if α=β+and g(β)=1B(f,g)=B(f,gβ)\f(B(f,gβ)) if α=β+and g(β)=0B(f,g)={B(f,gβ)β<α} if α is a limit ordinal. \begin{aligned} &B(f, g)=A \quad \text { if } \alpha=0, \\ &B(f, g)=f\left(B\left(f,\left.g\right|_{\beta}\right)\right) \quad \text { if } \alpha=\beta^{+} \text {and } g(\beta)=1 \\ &B(f, g)=B\left(f,\left.g\right|_{\beta}\right) \backslash f\left(B\left(f,\left.g\right|_{\beta}\right)\right) \quad \text { if } \alpha=\beta^{+} \text {and } g(\beta)=0 \\ &B(f, g)=\bigcap\left\{B\left(f,\left.g\right|_{\beta}\right) \mid \beta<\alpha\right\} \quad \text { if } \alpha \text { is a limit ordinal. } \end{aligned}

Show that, for any xAx \in A and any ordinal α\alpha, there exists a function gg with domain α\alpha such that xB(f,g)x \in B(f, g).

[It may help to observe that gg is uniquely determined by xx and α\alpha, though you need not show this explicitly.]

Show also that there exists α\alpha such that, for every gg with domain α,B(f,g)\alpha, B(f, g) is either empty or a singleton.

Deduce that the assertion 'Every set has a selection function' implies that every set can be totally ordered.

[Hartogs' Lemma may be assumed, provided you state it precisely.]